Mount Pocono is a central hub for visitors and residents in the Pocono Mountains region of Pennsylvania. Whether you are heading to a nearby resort, going for a hike, or just passing through, finding a reliable place for a quick and delicious meal is essential. Sandwiches are a popular choice in this area because they are portable, customizable, and satisfying.
This guide highlights the best sandwich options in and around Mount Pocono. We cover everything from traditional Italian hoagies and Philly-style cheesesteaks to artisanal paninis and breakfast sandwiches. You will find practical information on where to go, what to order, and how to get the best value for your meal.
Top Local Deli Favorites
When searching for a sandwich in Mount Pocono, local delis often provide the most authentic experience. These establishments typically use fresh bread from local bakeries and high-quality deli meats sliced to order. Supporting these local businesses often results in a more substantial and flavorful sandwich than what you might find at a national chain.
The Village Squirrel is one of the most well-known spots in the area. Located conveniently on PA-611, it offers a variety of specialty sandwiches and homemade soups. Their menu features creative combinations that go beyond the standard ham and cheese. It is a great choice for those looking for a high-quality lunch in a cozy environment.
Another staple is The Butcher Shoppe. While primarily a meat market, they serve some of the most highly-regarded sandwiches in the region. Because they are professional butchers, the quality of the roast beef, turkey, and ham is exceptional. Their sandwiches are known for being generously portioned, making them a favorite for hungry travelers.
Classic Pennsylvania Hoagies
In Pennsylvania, the “hoagie” is more than just a sub sandwich. It is a regional specialty characterized by a long, crusty roll, specific layering of meats, and the addition of shredded lettuce, onions, and tomatoes. In Mount Pocono, you can find several spots that take their hoagie preparation seriously.
- Italian Hoagies: Look for shops that use sharp provolone and a variety of Italian meats like salami, capicola, and prosciutto.
- Turkey and Cheese: A lighter option that remains a local favorite, often served with oil and vinegar rather than mayonnaise.
- Vegetarian Options: Many local delis offer “veggie hoagies” featuring roasted peppers, olives, and various cheeses.
When ordering a hoagie in Mount Pocono, it is common to be asked if you want “the works.” This usually includes lettuce, tomato, onion, and a blend of oil and oregano. If you prefer hot peppers or sweet peppers, be sure to specify that during the ordering process.
Hot Sandwiches and Cheesesteaks
Because Mount Pocono is located in Northeastern Pennsylvania, the influence of Philadelphia-style cheesesteaks is strong. Many local eateries offer their own take on this classic. A good cheesesteak in Mount Pocono will feature thinly sliced ribeye steak and melted cheese on a fresh long roll.
Muller’s Family Restaurant is a local landmark that offers a wide range of hot sandwiches. From classic clubs to hot open-faced turkey sandwiches with gravy, this is the place to go if you want a sit-down meal. Their sandwiches are consistent and provide a sense of traditional American comfort food.
For those looking for something pressed and crispy, look for menus featuring paninis. Several cafes in the area specialize in pressing sandwiches to order, which melts the cheese and toasts the bread perfectly. These are often served with a side of pasta salad or potato chips.
Breakfast Sandwiches for Early Travelers
Mount Pocono is a popular destination for early morning hikers and skiers. Consequently, the breakfast sandwich scene is quite active. The standard “Pork Roll, Egg, and Cheese” (also known as Taylor Ham) is a regional favorite that you must try if you are visiting from outside the Mid-Atlantic area.
Local gas stations and small convenience stores often have “grab-and-go” breakfast sandwiches that are surprisingly high quality. However, for a made-to-order breakfast sandwich, visiting a local bagel shop or a small diner like Pocono Summit West (just a short drive from the center of Mount Pocono) is recommended. They offer a variety of breads, including hard rolls, bagels, and croissants.
Quick Options and National Chains
If you are in a rush and need a predictable meal, Mount Pocono has several national and regional chains. These are often located along the main corridors of Route 611 and Route 940, making them very easy to access while traveling.
Wawa is a regional favorite that many visitors find impressive. They use a touch-screen ordering system that allows for total customization of your sandwich. Their hoagies are consistent, and they offer a wide variety of sides and drinks. It is a reliable 24-hour option for those arriving late or leaving early.
Other familiar names like Subway and Jersey Mike’s are also present in the area. These provide a familiar menu and are generally located in shopping plazas with ample parking. While they may lack the local flair of a small deli, they offer speed and nutritional information that some travelers prefer.
Tips for the Best Sandwich Experience
To ensure you get the best meal possible, keep a few local tips in mind. First, check the operating hours. Some of the best local delis in Mount Pocono are family-owned and may close earlier than chain restaurants, particularly on Sundays or Mondays.
Second, consider the season. During the peak summer and winter tourist seasons, popular sandwich shops can become very busy during the lunch rush (12:00 PM to 1:30 PM). If you are on a tight schedule, calling your order in ahead of time is a great way to save time.
Finally, ask about daily specials. Many Mount Pocono eateries create unique sandwiches based on seasonal ingredients or the butcher’s fresh cuts of the day. These specials are often the best value and offer the most interesting flavor profiles.
Dietary Considerations
If you have specific dietary needs, such as gluten-free or vegan requirements, your options in Mount Pocono are expanding. While traditional delis focus heavily on meat and wheat-based breads, many now offer lettuce wraps or gluten-free bread for a small additional charge.
For vegan travelers, look for shops that offer hummus wraps or roasted vegetable sandwiches. It is always helpful to call ahead to verify if a shop can accommodate specific allergies, as smaller kitchens may have limited space to prevent cross-contamination.
Conclusion
Mount Pocono offers a diverse range of sandwich options that cater to every taste and budget. From the high-quality meats at local butcher shops to the convenient customization of regional chains, you are sure to find a satisfying meal. Exploring the local deli scene is a great way to experience the flavor of the Poconos while fueling up for your adventures.
For more helpful guides on visiting the area, consider reading our articles on Best Hiking Trails in the Poconos or Where to Find Local Coffee in Monroe County. Safe travels and enjoy your meal!